Five Things we can Learn from Conservative Christians

Last Friday, I posted a piece titled “Nine Blessings from the Non-Conservative Christian Movement.”  I thought it would be interesting this Friday to swing that table around and write about things that non-conservatives can learn from conservatives. Keep in mind that when I talk about non-conservative and conservative Christians, I am talking about theology, not politics.  While theological and political leanings tend to be in the same direction, they aren’t always the same.

1)     The Importance of Community

Conservative Christians have been really good at forming a community where they feel welcomed and included.  In this community they raise their children, do life together, form a theological understanding together, and have a place to go to be prayed for and supported when needed.  They take seriously the biblical teaching not to forsake gathering together.

Lack of this kind of community is a real issue among many non-conservative believers.  It doesn’t help that many of the leaders of the non-conservative movement have declared that they have left the church.  I think of Barbara Brown Taylor in her book, “Leaving Church: A Memoir of Faith” where she not only hangs up her priestly attire, but says she feels at home on Sundays now just hanging out on her farm or attending a variety of different denominations with no church community to call her own.  Then there is Rachel Held-Evans who is just starting to “try on” church again after abandoning it for several years.  Brian McLaren’s article for the Huffington Post titled “Why we are Leaving Church” spoke to how church has become irrelevant for so many progressives.  And even Rob Bell left the church that he grew to mega-church proportions.

Granted, many non-conservatives have grown weary of being condemned by the church for their non-fundamentalist theology and have decided to go it alone.  Sometimes, they’ve even left church because they were asked to leave.  But it is time for non-conservatives to move beyond licking the deep wounds of exclusion and make “gathering together” a priority.  No one can optimally follow Christ without the support of other followers.  Community isn’t a nice to have.  Community is necessary in order to experience a healthy and complete spirituality – a place to be baptized, a place to take the Eucharist, and a place to serve the world together.  And even a place that will help you raise your kids and take care of you when you most need it.

I am not suggesting that non-conservatives return to the churches they fled.  There are churches and whole denominations who want you just as you are.  I think the best Christian communities are the ones that welcome both conservative and non-conservative theology.  But don’t stop until you find a community where you are wanted.  I’d advise you to keep looking if they don’t allow the full inclusion of women and LGBTQ in their leadership and clergy.

2)     An Attraction to Bible Study

Conservatives place a high importance on Bible study.  They often teach that Bible study is the primary way that church members experience spiritual growth.  I don’t really agree with that line of thinking any longer.  I think worship, the practice of spiritual disciplines, and prayer are every bit as important for spiritual growth – if not more important.  However, I grieve that so many non-conservatives have been turned off to Bible study.  But I can see why.  So many Bible studies – instead of challenging the student to dig in and discuss challenging questions – just declare worn out dogmatic answers.

But the Bible is fascinating when one digs in.  I love studying this ancient text and pouring over its mysteries – from five thousand year old accounts of encounters with God to the closest friends of Jesus recording their insights and impressions of the Messiah.

If you’ve perused the rest of my website, you know Bible study is my thing.  When I grow up, I’d like to be the non-conservative, less well dressed, never in your face version of Beth Moore.  Or maybe the more humorous, generator of questions with less hard and fast answers, hippie version of Kay Arthur.  I am in the process of considering a contract offer on my first book – a parable that teaches the Epistle of James – so keep this in mind later in the year if you get the hankering for studying scripture!

3)     The Necessity of Financial Giving

Conservatives have long taught that all members should give at least 10% of their earnings to God.  I think we can debate the need for a hard and fast percentage, but we can’t debate that non-conservatives should be pooling their resources to serve God and others.  However, studies show that when non-conservatives join a church, they do not contribute much of anything financially until they have been members for at least five years.  It is likely that they feel the need to stick around long enough to be assured their money isn’t going towards buying the pastor a second home in the Cayman Islands.

It is important that you find a great church and contribute financially – otherwise there won’t be any non-conservative churches left!  And support your non-conservative clergy by paying them a fair wage and providing benefits.

4)     A Willingness to Call-Out Sin

Conservatives focus mostly on personal sins (think sex, drugs, and rock-n-roll) and non-conservatives focus more on corporate sins (think all manner of social injustices).  Overlooking our different definitions of sin, conservatives aren’t afraid to yell “sinner” when they see one.  Conservatives believe that certain people are evil and that it is their duty to name the offenders and beat them down.

On the other hand, non-conservatives tend to believe that humans are basically good.  However, that doesn’t really explain slavery, human trafficking, 9/11, violence against women, poverty, the Boston marathon bombing, pollution, global warming, or Sandy Hook.

Non-conservatives might want to rethink the possibility of the existence of an unseen, supernatural, organized “evil” in the world.  Perhaps evil does exist and, in fact, has an agenda to destroy all that is innocent and good.  Non-conservatives need to learn to name evil (which is different from yelling “sinner”), identify its agenda, and fight it.  Of course, non-conservatives would fight it using non-violent means like education and working justice out in the legal system.  Even so, non-conservatives should never stop holding onto hope that all humans basically want to be good and do good.

5)     Zeal for Evangelism

Conservatives (sometimes synonymous with the term evangelical) make it a priority to invite outsiders to become one of them, while non-conservatives aren’t quite sure what to do with Jesus’ command to “go into all the world.”  Personally, I distinguish between being evangelical and being evangelistic.  For me, “evangelical” has come to mean, “my goal is for you to become like me in my faith so that your salvation is assured.”  Whereas “evangelistic” means “you have an open invitation to join with me in seeking the way of Christ together.”  We may evangelize for different reasons, but non-conservatives clearly need to get better at unapologetically inviting the stranger into their communities.  Non-conservatives need to start accepting that having the stranger join them is good for everyone.  More friends and a richer life for existing members.  But it’s good for the stranger too, because our communities are committed to accepting, loving, and serving them in the way of Christ.  We need to believe that what our communities offer is valuable!

Well, that does it.  Five things non-conservatives can learn from conservatives!  Would love to hear your comments.  In closing, whether you are a conservative Christian or a non-conservative Christian, here is a mystery for all of us to ponder…

John said to Jesus, “Teacher, we saw someone casting out demons in your name, and we tried to stop him, because he was not following us.”  But Jesus said, “Do not stop him; for no one who does a deed of power in my name will be able soon afterward to speak evil of me.  Whoever is not against us is for us” (Mark 9:38-40 NRS).


April is a progressive Christian who writes about scripture and spiritual disciplines. See her latest book, James in the Suburbs.  

28 Comments on “Five Things we can Learn from Conservative Christians

  1. Pingback: Welcome to My blog | April Love-Fordham

  2. Very interesting and very accurate points, as was the previous one. I have also begun listening to your series on Galatians. We have very similar approaches though I am a writer rather than a speaker, generally speaking. I have written mainly on the Penteteuch so far but just this year felt drawn to Galatians and have been writing through it verse by verse. My wife is an Episcopal priest here in a little parish in upstate NY, but in my youth I lived in Georgia, near Macon. At any rate, may God’s peace and blessing be on your work.


    • Thank you so much! I just signed a contract on my first book! It is a parable/commentary on the Epistle of James. Blessings on your writing!


  3. Hearing via email from a lot of people who have felt rejected by church. Keep this in mind…

    People who are truly followers of Jesus love you. Period. Not because you meet some theological or political or lifestyle test. In fact, not because of anything you do or don’t do. They love you because of who they are – people transformed by Christ’s love. There is nothing you have to do to prove yourselves to them, because they are already convinced that you are amazing simply because they know your creator made great stuff! So if you aren’t loved in “a” church that is simply because you haven’t found “the” church. Don’t give up looking for it, it is out there!


  4. Where can I find a non-conservative church in the Ft. LAUDERDALE, FL area?

    Thank you.


    • There is an open & affirming United Church of Christ that is also fully accessible in Fort Lauderdale.


  5. Hey Denise, isn’t it that the other name for Jesus is love (Mt 25)? Yes, April, great lessons for non-conservatives – and for conservatives, too.


  6. Dear April,

    I did appreciate your article. I guess you would call me a conservative evangelical. I attend a very large non-denominational church. I was raised in a very legalistic Nazarene home. I just want people everywhere to know Jesus. That is where life begins. I am concerned that Progressive Christianity focuses on social issues, and most of these are political right now. I feel that love is becoming the progressive’s God. I am sure that Jesus would be very saddened by this. He is so much more than love and acceptance and etc. He is the one and only standard for our life. Have a great new year. Denise


    • You do understand Jesus dealt with social and political issues, right? The prostitute, tax collectors(if that isn’t a political issue even back then, I don’t know what to say) lepers, the Samaritan woman by the well. Or is all that progressive and libral fake news? Text can be hard to understand so I wish to mention this is not to make you feel threatened, bash or minimize your opinion. Unfortunately we have gotten to this point.


  7. Both this post and the one last week are spot on! I am in a tough place right now myself because of each of these things. Getting set to leave my denomination of 50 years of life to go to one (if the church start-up succeeds) which more closely matches my theology. My fondest hope is that the new start-up will take into account ALL of the things you have said because that is the kind of church of which I want to be a part.


  8. This was a good article, in my open-minded conservative Christian view. I didn’t care for the way the Pat Robertson clip was presented. He’s from another generation, and he’s a flawed individual like the rest of us. He’s not always going to get it exactly right. I think he’s done a lot of good for a lot of people.


  9. I love this piece. It reminds me of what Brian McLaren has written about, that conservative Christians tend to be strong on identity but hostile towards “the world” while progressives tend to be weak on identity but benevolent. We need to be strong and benevolent.


  10. Just shared this on FB with the following: Amen amen and amen! I grew up conservative evangelical. I’m now a progressive Christian who is also a universalist. I spend a lot of time in the gap between the two parts of the family, challenging each side to honor the gifts the other brings. I learned MUCH from the faith of my youth and so much of who I am today is because of the Southern Baptist Church that raised me. But when they could no longer make a home for me, the United Church of Christ adopted me and helped me heal, saw my gifts and graces and accepted and affirmed my call to ministry and ordained me. The progressive Christian community has given me a language and theology that better matches how I’ve always felt (i.e., with an emphasis on justice for all ala Micah 6:8). But I’ve missed the emphasis on community and individual spiritual disciplines of my conservative roots, and I’m saddened by a biblical illiteracy in the non-conservative community that leaves many missing the gifts that lie under the layers of dogma and allows a more conservative interpretation of scripture to be seen as the only one! God bless you, April Love Fordham, and May peace be with you as you work towards your goal.


  11. Very well-thought out article. I have been thinking lately about how I can be more accepting of conservative Christians and conservative people. Here are 5 reasons why what they bring to the table can’t be overlooked.

    Another subject of interest would be not just “how should we copy their behaviors while throwing out their bad dogma”, but “how can it be that some of their dogma is right and we just don’t want to admit it”. For instance, if God really was vengeful, would you still serve God?


  12. The United Church of Christ is a wonderful. progressive, socially progressive church and does all of the things you call “conservative” very well. Maybe with the exception of the acknowledging evil.


  13. I was a little confused at first because the only time I have ever had a sense of community or attraction Bible Study were in less conservative churches and although every church I have been to states the need for financial giving only my less conservative church has sparked a strong desire to do so, but I do agree whole heartedly with number 4 and 5!


  14. Great post April! For me, the community I have found in the church has been one of the greatest blessings, one that can be hard to explain. You have captured it here.


    • Me too!! I think our church is extra special. I like the theological diversity and concern for one another. Plus the clergy are awesome! 🙂


  15. Pingback: Nine Blessings from the Non-Conservative Christian Movement | Dr. April Love-Fordham


Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s